Sherwin-Williams signs with IndyCar MLS, SNHU sign new partnership The Lefton Report: Playing it Safelite Mike Slive: Going out on top Precourt thoughtful in remaking Crew Challenging schools on cheating DraftKings closes on $300M funding round NBC readies year-out efforts for Games Best opportunities outside of teams Fanatics' new era of racetrack retail
SBJ/March 31-April 6, 2014/In DepthPrint All
The 25-year-old, dyed-in-the-wool Pittsburgh Steelers fan couldn’t believe his eyes. Bill Cowher angrily stormed toward him, approaching on the grounds of the old Municipal Stadium in Cleveland, his trademark spittle flying.
Don Cornwell, a young staffer at the NFL in 1994, had gotten the short end of the stick one fall weekend to fly in from New York to enforce league uniform rules before that day’s Browns-Steelers dustup. He had just informed Steelers staff that Greg Lloyd, a recidivist fashion rule breaker, had his socks too high. That meant Lloyd returning to the locker room to change, which could have caused the linebacker to miss the start of the game. Cowher would have none of it.
Cornwell, who remained such a big fan of the Steelers that several years ago he went to their fantasy camp, moved on from his sock inspection days (he was an analyst with the league for two years). He is now a managing director at Morgan Stanley where he is one of the top dealmakers in sports, overseeing the sales of IMG (pending) and Maple Leaf Sport & Entertainment, and yes, the restructuring of the Steelers.
He is rare in sports, a top acquisitions adviser at a major investment bank. Unlike traditional commercial sectors, in sports, boutique agencies play an outsized role in mergers and acquisitions, or M&A. The sale of the Sacramento Kings, the biggest team sale last year, for example, engaged three boutiques: Game Plan advising the buyer, GSP the seller, and Tipping Point Sports the spurned Seattle group.
Part of the reason for the lower profile of big investment banks is the unique and heavily nuanced aspects of the sports industry, and in particular the leagues’ heavily regulated approach to their business. It’s also the slower deal flow, and for Wall Street, the often small numbers.
Of course, with the $2.15 billion sale of the Los Angeles Dodgers, soaring regional sports network valuations, and ancillary value outside of teams, like in IMG, Cornwell is relishing the opportunity.
“What has happened over the past four or five years with the increase in media revenues and stabilization of cost structures with the new CBAs is that the profitability of these franchises has gone up,” he said. “With cash flows up, you see nontraditional sports buyers like private equity funds looking at them. Historically, they would never. I am not seeing a lot of traditional PE firms buying teams outright, but they are looking at ways of getting into the sports ecosystem.”
Following the footsteps
Cornwell was born into a banking family, named after his father who worked in investment banking and then
Cornwell’s current portfolio includes overseeing the pending sale of IMG.
Photo by:Patrick E. McCarthy
In Cornwell’s early days at Morgan Stanley, which he joined in 1998 out of Stanford Business School, many people did a double take when he walked into meetings, expecting an older version to walk through the doors. It’s one of the reasons Cornwell adopted using K, his middle initial, ahead of his first name upon introduction and on business cards, to ensure those who heard his name for the first time distinguished him from his father.
Cornwell majored in government at Harvard, his father’s alma mater. And fresh out of school, he joined McKinsey, the consulting firm, before joining the NFL and later going to graduate school.
Eric Baker, the CEO of European ticketing firm Viagogo, is a Cornwell friend dating to their days at the consulting firm and Stanford.
“He is on the short list of guys I call to get perspective on sports deals,” said Baker, who boasts a summer home in the Hamptons close to Cornwell’s. “He always has his pulse on what is going on in sports.”
“I remember [Commissioner Paul] Tagliabue came by and just introduced himself, and one of the first things he said was, ‘You know I held the record for rebounding at Georgetown before Patrick Ewing,’” Cornwell recounted.
He worked there with future Commissioner Roger Goodell, Joe Siclare, now the chief financial officer, and Joe Ellis, today the Denver Broncos president. Tom Spock, then the head of NFL Enterprises, wrote a letter of recommendation for Cornwell to Stanford.
“Don has a great personality,” said Spock, who is a media consultant now. “He lives in a larger world than just the world of his office.”
Perhaps it is coincidental that for his first major sports transaction Cornwell advised Dan and Art Rooney on the restructure of the Steelers after the league ruled that family members’ ownership of horse tracks violated league anti-gambling rules.
The deal involved debt, equity, reshuffling and selling partnership interests, all on the heels of the 2008 financial crash.
“It wasn’t an easy time,” said Art Rooney, the Steelers’ owner now. Cornwell could get excited at times trying to get certain deal points together, Rooney said.
“I am happy he was our financial adviser,” Rooney said.
Not all of Cornwell’s work is as high profile. He advises the NBA on the valuation of team media contracts, which is a controversial area when a team that owns its rights can value them less than market rate for the purposes of limiting their payments into revenue sharing.
“Teams have their views on media valuations so we rely on experts,” said Bill Koenig, the NBA’s president of global media distribution.
Cornwell will say little about his most high-profile assignment, co-advising on the sale of IMG to William Morris Endeavor, even long after the sides announced the transaction.
That transaction tested him, with frequent erroneous media reports, the high-profile nature of IMG, and the lengths he had to go through to keep the process quiet, underscored by his continued reticence.
Clearly though he values IMG’s media assets, believing that there is nowhere to go but up.
“Today we get the question, ‘Is there a bubble in the value of sports rights?’ ” Cornwell said. “My own personal view is there is not.”
Cornwell, as the son of African-American bankers, said he feels a strong need to give back to his community.
“Both my parents were African-Americans on Wall Street in the ’70s and ’80s, so I had a first-row seat for what they went through,” he said. “Frankly [there are] not a lot of African-Americans on Wall Street today, so it always amazes me what they went through.”
He chose education as his focus, sitting on the board of directors for a charter school in Brooklyn, and the East Harlem Tutorial Program, a 56-year mainstay in the underprivileged neighborhood.
“He is incredibly committed, he is co-chair of [the] fundraising and communications committees, which means he attends eight board meetings a year and even hosts an annual event,” said Jeff Ginsburg, who runs the charity. “When you go to that event, you see that Don has a lot of friends.”
Founder, Inner Circle Sports
It was a banner year for Inner Circle, with advisory roles on the sales of the Florida Panthers, New Jersey Devils and Phoenix Coyotes in 2013. Inner Circle’s biggest deal since Tilliss started the firm in 2002 was advising Fenway Sports on the 2009 purchase of Liverpool Football Club. Tilliss formed Inner Circle after running JPMorgan Chase’s sports lending practice.
Photo by:Galatioto Sports Partners
President, Galatioto Sports Partners
One of the more entertaining personalities in the sports finance world, Galatioto’s firm advised the Maloofs last year on the sale of the Sacramento Kings. GSP played a central role in the bankruptcy saga of the Texas Rangers, helping force the team to auction against MLB’s wishes.
Photo by: Markswisher.com
Chairman & CEO, Moag & Co.
Moag was the chairman of the Maryland Stadium Commission in 1995 when the state struck the deal to lure the Browns from Cleveland. From that he launched his sports career, and over the years has advised on the sales of the Ravens and Dolphins, and more recently the San Diego Padres.
Photo by:Tipping Point Sports
CEO, Tipping Point Sports
Ziets is an expert in stadium lease negotiations, having worked with a variety of teams, including the San Diego Chargers. He advised the ill-fated Seattle group’s push to buy the Kings, and now is involved in efforts to bring the NHL to Seattle.
Managing director, Allen & Co.
Greenberg has long since moved beyond being known as Hank Greenberg’s son. He is the go-to guy for MLB team sales and transactions, and has frequently been rumored as a candidate for commissioner of the sport. He is not limited to MLB, however, and now is advising the Milwaukee Bucks on a prospective sale of the club.
Vataha (left) and Caporale made their mark advising on team sales.
Photo by:Chris Churchill
Chairman, Game Plan
CEO, Game Plan
A two-man shop with offices out of their homes on the respective coasts, Game Plan features Caporale and Vataha, a former Patriots wide receiver. They have long made a mark advising on team sales, including last year’s Kings transaction, representing the buyer. Over the years they have advised on the sale of the Golden State Warriors and Boston Celtics, and once even advised Bain & Co. on a bid to buy the entire NHL.
Rising equity markets, owner friendly collective-bargaining agreements, healthy business metrics. Despite these factors blessing sports leagues, or perhaps because of them, the sale of teams has been sluggish at best.
In Major League Baseball, for example, there has not been a sale of a team in two years, the last being the San Diego Padres and the Los Angeles Dodgers.
Currently, only one team in the top four leagues is officially on the market, the Milwaukee Bucks (Greenberg is the adviser).
Sports teams can sell for a few reasons, ranging from personal issues (a divorce drove the Padres sale) to financial problems facing the owner. The new CBAs, by better controlling labor costs, have made owning a team a less financially risky prospect, reducing red-ink induced sales.
“People are holding on because media rights continue to rise,” said Sal Galatioto, whose Galatioto Sports Partners
The San Diego Padres are the last team to sell in Major League Baseball.
Photo by:Getty Images
Four years ago the mergers and acquisitions market was still recovering from the financial crisis, so the comparison is a stark one.
Galatioto for one is busying his firm with the sale of limited partnership stakes. That market has risen with limited partnership positions now one of the only ways to get ownership in sports, even if it doesn’t bring control.
Not all agree the M&A market is quiet. Rob Tilliss, founder of Inner Circle Sports, had a busy year in 2013, advising on the sale of the NHL’s Florida Panthers and New Jersey Devils, to name a few. The financing markets are offering cheap money, he said, making it easier for buyers to cover rising values.
“It is a small number of lenders, but they are hungry, and they are active,” he said.
But Tilliss is an outlier with his opinion.
Take Bob Caporale, chairman of Game Plan, who said that while it may be a matter of simple timing, the market for big league sports teams is very quiet.
That all said, there are other markets. Major League Soccer has seen several team sales, and many investment bankers are working overseas in European soccer. And there are a steady stream of ancillary sports deals, ranging from marketing agencies to technology companies.
That may be where the juice in the sports mergers and acquisitions market stays, the bankers say. With satisfaction high from owning a team, and financial losses rare, Greenberg’s question is this: “Why would you ever sell one of these things?”
■ Seller: Maloof family
■ Buyer: Vivek Ranadivé
■ Price: $534 million
Note: Less than two weeks after buying controlling interest, the Ranadivé Group purchased another 7 percent share to bring the total to 72 percent ownership of the team.
New Jersey Devils
■ Seller: Jeff Vanderbeek
■ Buyer: Josh Harris and David Blitzer
■ Price: $320 million
■ Seller: Cliff Viner
■ Buyer: Vincent Viola
■ Price: $250 million
■ Seller: NHL
■ Buyer: Ice Arizona Acquisitions Co., a group headed by George Gosbee and Anthony LeBlanc
■ Price: $170 million
■ Seller: Hunt Sports Group
■ Buyer: Precourt Sports Ventures
■ Price: $68 million
■ Seller: Molson Coors sold its 14.5 percent stake in the franchise.
■ Buyer: Arizona developer Jay Stein
Note: Sale ends the equity ownership the brewer has held in the club since the team’s inception in 1991.
■ Seller: Jorge Vergara and Angelica Fuentes
■ Buyer: MLS
Note: Published media reports listed the price of the sale, which closed in February, at $70 million. The league is actively looking to resell the club to a new ownership group.
■ Seller: Forstmann Little & Co.
■ Buyer: William Morris Endeavor Entertainment with private equity backer Silver Lake Partners
■ Price: $2.4 billion
Note: Auction was run by investment banks Evercore Partners and Morgan Stanley
■ Seller: Arbitron
■ Buyer: Nielsen Holdings
■ Price: $1.26 billion
■ Seller: Easton-Bell Sports
■ Buyer: Bauer Performance Sports
■ Price: $330 million
Outdoor Channel Holdings
■ Seller: Outdoor Channel Holdings
■ Buyer: Kroenke Sports & Entertainment
■ Price: $265 million
■ Seller: Harris Interactive
■ Buyer: Nielsen Holdings
■ Price: $116.6 million
■ Seller: Quiksilver
■ Buyer: Extreme Holdings
■ Price: $58 million
■ Seller: Quiksilver
■ Buyer: Cherokee
■ Price: $19 million
Game On Sports
■ Seller: Game On Sports
■ Buyer: Lids Sports Group
■ Price: N/A
■ Seller: Digital Scout
■ Buyer: PlayOn! Sports
■ Price: N/A
■ Seller: SportStream (owned by Vulcan Capital and Trail Blazers Inc.)
■ Buyer: Facebook
■ Price: N/A
■ Seller: Sports Propaganda
■ Buyer: That’s My Ticket
■ Price: N/A
Immagine & Sport
■ Seller: Immagine & Sport
■ Buyer: Repucom
■ Price: N/A
■ Seller: Nelligan Sports
■ Buyer: Learfield Sports
Note: Providence Equity had acquired Learfield for more than $500 million in September 2013.
Omnicom Group and Publicis Groupe
■ Price: $35.1 billion
Note: The company will be called Publicis Omnicom Group
Source: SportsBusiness Journal research