Pitt Names Utah State's Barnes Next AD Pitt Hires Utah State's Barnes As AD Emmert Calls For End Of One-And-Done Clemson Coach Critical Of Cost Of Attendance Longhorns Exploring Int'l Brand Exposure Wichita State Promotes Sexton, Boatwright SEC's Mike Slive In Good Spirits NCAA, Defense Dept. Launch Concussion Study Ole Miss AD Bjork Signs Four-Year Extension Mid-Majors Face Cost-Of-Attendance Choices
Upcoming Conferences and Events
SBD/February 21, 2013/Colleges
NCAA "Likely" To Hear Miami Case In July; Shalala's Aggressive Tactics Garner Attention
Published February 21, 2013
BRINGING THE THUNDER: USA TODAY’s George Schroeder reports UM President Donna Shalala is “politely declining interview requests for the time being, which perhaps isn’t surprising.” But UM’s “abrupt reversal from quiet cooperation to public defiance is startling” after the NCAA's ruling. The language in Shalala’s public statements this week was “unusual for a university administrator, especially before an NCAA investigation is completed.” Ohio Univ. sports administration professor David Ridpath said, “In many ways she’s thrown down the gauntlet and challenged (the NCAA): ‘Bring it on.’” Schroeder notes Shalala’s statements “played well with many, perhaps because of the natural antipathy held by many college football fans for the NCAA and especially its enforcement arm” (USA TODAY, 2/21). In Ft. Lauderdale, Dave Hyde writes Shalala “wants to bring media and public opinion down on the NCAA in a maneuver that will reduce the coming punishment.” Hyde: “Maybe it works on the NCAA's ruling body, the Committee of Infractions. Maybe it backfires.” The media is Shalala’s “great ally now.” Both UM and the NCAA “needed strong leaders at defining times.” Both, “unfortunately and unmistakably, came up lacking” (South Florida SUN-SENTINEL, 2/21). ESPN.com’s Heather Dinich asked, “You think Shalala’s gonna back down from NCAA president Mark Emmert and his Notice of Allegations? Puh-lease. Let the arm-wrestling begin” (ESPN.com, 2/20). In West Palm Beach, Dave George writes Shalala “senses a weakness here and she’s eager to exploit it” (PALM BEACH POST, 2/21). In Miami, Greg Cote writes the NCAA -- “corrupted, embarrassed and now playing the obstinate bully -- has managed to do the seemingly impossible: It has cast the University of Miami as the sympathetic victim.” Cote gives credit to Shalala, who has “turned into Hurricane Donna, in standing up to this nonsense.” Shalala has “become a bantam force righteously blasting the NCAA” (MIAMI HERALD, 2/21). ESPN’s Andy Katz said, “You’re looking at a new shift where university presidents, athletic directors and coaches are going to fight back now" ("Outside The Lines," ESPN, 2/20). But in Tampa, Gary Shelton wrote that both the NCAA and school administrators are at fault, stating, “No matter how badly the NCAA embarrassed itself, and the word ‘thoroughly’ comes to mind, Miami’s administration should have done better” (TAMPA BAY TIMES, 2/20).
|Critics say Emmert's position has been weakened due to UM investigation|
START FROM SCRATCH: In DC, John Feinstein writes the NCAA’s enforcement “debacle is not what ails the NCAA, and neither is Emmert.” Both are “symptoms of a system gone wrong, one that needs to be abandoned.” The NCAA’s “time has passed.” Collegiate sports can “no longer be run with an iron fist -- especially an incompetent one.” Not only is Emmert’s status “under no threat -- the presidents aren’t going to humiliate one of their own -- any replacement approved by that group isn’t going to be substantially different.” But even if the NCAA had “competent leadership, it would be time to start all over again.” Football, men’s basketball and non-revenue sports each “should have a commissioner.” SEC Commissioner Mike Slive “would be a reasonable choice to run football.” Potential basketball choices “could include” former Big East Commissioner Mike Tranghese or former NCAA Senior VP/Basketball & Business Strategies Greg Shaheen. The presidents “should be completely removed from the process except (perhaps) to help in fundraising at their schools” (WASHINGTON POST, 2/21).
THE END OF THE NCAA? ESPN’s Tom Farrey said the NCAA “is at a serious crossroads” and in terms of the future, “it’s really going to come down to what the commissioners of the BCS conferences want." Farrey: "If they feel like the NCAA is going to be an effective mechanism moving forward for them to pursue their own interests, then they’ll support it. If not, there’s no reason they couldn’t break off and create their own organization” (“Outside The Lines,” ESPN, 2/20). The L.A. Times' Plaschke suggested the possible future of the NCAA “could be a whole other organizing body." However, college presidents "have to agree on this, and they’re not going to do it. ... They love the NCAA, they love what it represents” (“Around The Horn,” ESPN, 2/20).
AND ONE MORE BLEMISH ON NCAA: In Newark, Steve Politi reports the Montclair State Univ. women’s basketball team will be “barred from hosting NCAA Tournament games because the association is still angry about New Jersey’s law that legalizes sports betting.” Politi: “Forget that the law is still the subject of what will be a lengthy court battle.” The NCAA, in the “eyes of many, is broken and beyond fixing” (Newark STAR-LEDGER, 2/21).