Minding My Business: Seahawks' Jeff Dunn NFL Panthers Battling Wi-Fi Issues NBA Owners Vote Down Lottery Reform Efforts Rice Files Formal Grievance Against Ravens NFL Teams Going Through Domestic Violence Training NFL Sends Out Survey To L.A. Residents Bears' Gould Featured In H.H. Gregg Ad CFP, Cowboys Playoffs Could Conflict NHL Takes Swift Action On Voynov NFL Conducting Market Research In L.A.
Upcoming Conferences and Events
SBD/November 19, 2012/Leagues and Governing Bodies
NFL To Convert To Electronic Health Records In Effort To Address Concussions
Published November 19, 2012
DISABILITY PAYOUT: ESPN's "Outside the Lines" and PBS' "Frontline" in a joint investigation found that the NFL's retirement board "awarded disability payments to at least three former players after concluding that football caused their crippling brain injuries -- even as the league's top medical experts for years consistently denied any link between the sport and long-term brain damage." Documents obtained in the investigation show that he board paid at least $2M in disability benefits to the players in the late '90s and '00s (ESPN.com, 11/16). NFL Senior VP/PR Greg Aiello said the ESPN report “underscores that we have had a system in place with the union for many years to address player injury claims on a case-by-case basis.” Aiello added the disability plan was “collectively bargained with the players.” Aiello: “All decisions concerning player injury claims are made by the disability plan’s board, not by the NFL or by the Players Association” (N.Y. TIMES, 11/17).
NO SMOKING GUN: PRO FOOTBALL TALK's Mike Florio noted ESPN's “supposed bombshell in the concussion cases against the NFL, while not erroneous in its factual content, makes an illogical leap in interpretation.” Specifically, cases from the NFL’s disability board in which "benefits were paid to former players for long-term health consequences are being characterized by ESPN as the ‘smoking gun’ in the concussion litigation brought by former players.” Florio: “Apart from the fact that the information has been well known for years and the NFL’s disability board is independent from the league, the fact that the board consists of representatives from both the NFL and the NFLPA underscores the fact that the players’ union (i.e., the players themselves) had an integral role in the development of knowledge and/or the alleged concealment of it from players.” Florio wrote it has been a “rough year" for "OTL.” Florio: “From the Bernie Fine fiasco or the Mickey Loomis wiretap witch hunt, Bristol’s investigative unit has been doing plenty of swinging -- and plenty of missing” (PROFOOTBALLTALK.com, 11/17). In Boston, Greg Bedard wrote "something seems amiss" on the ESPN story. Bedard: “If the NFL gave the players a check, then they have something. But the board is independent of the league and includes player representatives. So if you’re saying the NFL was covering something up, then the NFLPA wasn’t exactly in the dark” (BOSTON GLOBE, 11/18).
TAKING EVERY PRECAUTION? The GLOBE's Bedard wrote the NFL has “come a very long way in a very short period of time.” Bedard: “Whether they led or were dragged kicking and screaming will be addressed with the many concussion lawsuits.” The “next leap is going to come in a couple of years” when new equipment is “ready to be used.” Concussions at that point “will be much easier to diagnose and in a more timely matter.” But what happened last weekend has “led to questions about whether the league is doing everything it can right now.” Bedard: “The NFL does have the ability to put an independent neurologist on each sideline -- something the Players Association has asked for -- yet it has not done so. Why?” (BOSTON GLOBE, 11/18). But CBS’ Dr. Neal ElAttrache said the on-field diagnosis and management of concussions is “still best done between the player and the doctor that knows him best, and that’s the team physician.” ElAttrache: “Doing that says one of two things if you put these guys on the sidelines. It either says that the experienced team physicians are not competent to make the diagnosis and to manage it on the field or that they’re conflicted and wouldn’t do it properly. I can tell you that neither one of these things is the case. I really think that this is still a diagnosis best made between the player on the field and the doctor that knows him best” (“The NFL Today,” CBS, 11/18).
FORMER PLAYERS NEED HELP: NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell spoke at the Harvard School of Public Health last week, and the AP’s Tim Dahlberg wrote Goodell’s “timing seemed odd,” with his speech “coming after a week in which three starting NFL quarterbacks were knocked out of games with concussions.” Dahlberg: “No matter, because the NFL commissioner is nothing if not a spin doctor extraordinaire.” However, Goodell’s speech “left unsaid” what to do “with the players of the past.” In addition to changing the current game, there is “something else the NFL can change.” Dahlberg: “Doing something to improve the lives of the guys who helped get the league where it is today would be a good place to start” (AP, 11/17).