WME-IMG Hires Chris Liddell As New CFO NCAA Concussion Settlement Faces Scrutiny Minding My Business With Brandon Igdalsky Flood Damages UCLA's Pauley Pavilion Raiders' Davis Eyeing San Antonio As New Home? Michele Roberts Sold Players On Union Vision Stephen A. Smith Suspended One Week AFib Awareness Promoted At Chicago Chase Race MLB's MASN Ruling Favors Nationals Classified Advertisements
SBD/May 17, 2011/Leagues and Governing BodiesPrint All
The NFL won a significant victory at the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals last night, with the court keeping in place the lockout and strongly suggesting it would ultimately overturn a lower court’s decision declaring the lockout illegal. Nine active players sued the NFL, seeking a ruling the lockout was illegal because the union had decertified. The decision could shift the dynamics of the 67-day lockout, with the owners for the first time securing leverage. “In sum, we have serious doubts that the district court had jurisdiction to enjoin the League’s lockout, and accordingly conclude that the League has made a strong showing that it is likely to succeed on the merits,” two of the three judge panel wrote. The third dissented. The two judges seemed to accept the league’s argument that the lower court, which ruled for the players April 25, was constrained by the Norris-LaGuardia Act from involving itself in a labor dispute. In fact, the two judges used harsh language to describe their opinion of the lower court, using phrases like “we have serious doubts,” “we struggle … to see,” and “raise serious questions.” One of the league’s points is that a period of time needed to elapse between the decertification of the union and the collective bargaining process before antitrust litigation could be filed. U.S. District Judge Susan Nelson criticized the NFL for putting a “temporal gloss,” on when a union can disband. In turn, judges Steven Colloton and Duane Benton wrote, “Given the close temporal and substantive relationship linking this case with the labor dispute between League and the Players’ union, we struggle at this juncture to see why this case is not at least one 'growing out of a labor dispute' -- even under the district court’s view that union involvement is required for a labor dispute." Judge Kermit Bye dissented, saying the decision puts any union in an impossible situation of never being able to decertify. A union cannot sue an employer for antitrust claims, but if it disbands, the employees can.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT? The players brief is due in the 8th Circuit on Friday, with oral arguments scheduled for June 3, and a decision likely in the following month. It is unclear how this decision will affect the second day of mediated talks between the NFL and players in Minnesota federal court starting this morning. After the 8th Circuit ruled, the NFL put out a statement saying the dispute would be solved at the bargaining table. NFLPA Exec Dir DeMaurice Smith put out his own statement, saying the players have long prepared for a lockout (Daniel Kaplan, SportsBusiness Journal). In Boston, Greg Bedard notes a decision is "not expected for another 4-6 weeks." Whichever way the court decides, the NFL and the players "still would have enough time" to reach a new CBA, "start free agency, and open training camps on time in late July." But that is "only if the losing side does not appeal to the entire 11-judge panel at the 8th Circuit, or to the US Supreme Court." In the meantime, the NFL "won its first battle in this legal fight -- and it appears, for now, to be a big one" (BOSTON GLOBE, 5/17). In DC, Mark Maske notes if the two sides "don’t reach a negotiated agreement, it is difficult to predict how long the overall court process could take." But legal experts have said that the court "could take weeks, or longer, to rule after it holds the hearing June 3" (WASHINGTON POST, 5/17). ESPN's Tony Kornheiser said, "I think the owners want to play. I think the players want to play. ... But they also want to win. Both sides, owners and players, want to win and they've been presented with the possibility legally that they can win" ("PTI," ESPN, 5/16).
SCORE ONE FOR THE OWNERS: In N.Y., Bart Hubbuch writes the decision from the "decidedly conservative-leaning 8th Circuit is a stinging blow to the players, who until last night had been riding a wave of favorable court rulings since the lockout began in early March" (N.Y. POST, 5/17). YAHOO SPORTS' Doug Farrar wrote yesterday's decision was the "first real victory for the league in a court of law in a very long time" (SPORTS.YAHOO.com, 5/16). FOXSPORTS.com's Alex Marvez wrote under the header, "NFL Owners Get Big Win In Lockout Ruling" (FOXSPORTS.com, 5/16). ESPN's Adam Schefter said it was "a complete and total victory for the NFL owners." Schefter: "Keep in mind, this is what the NFL owners were targeting all along. ... The NFL has always wanted this to go on for a while. The league felt that the longer this went on the more it worked to the league's advantage because players do not get paychecks until the season starts" ("SportsCenter," ESPN, 5/16). Former National Labor Relations Board Chair William Gould suggested that the "specter of a loss in the 8th Circuit could wind up forcing the players back to the bargaining table" (L.A. TIMES, 5/17). CBSSPORTS.com's Clark Judge writes the 8th Circuit Court "delivered the NFL a triumph so decisive it could force players into retreat." Until now, the players "believed -- and with good reason -- that their best interests rested with the courts, and until now they had the record to prove it." But yesterday's ruling "wasn't just a defeat for players; it was Gettysburg" (CBSSPORTS.com, 5/17). CBSSPORTS.com's Mike Freeman wrote, "The players have been defeated. The owners have probably won. The only thing left to do in this ugly, brutal fight is for the owners to decide what to do with the carcass. ... Dragging this out only makes it worse for fans. This is now like the end of an election where a network has declared one side the victor and the loser refuses to accept it's over" (CBSSPORTS.com, 5/16).
Doty's ruling has become even more important
following ruling from appellate court
NICE TO SEE YOU AGAIN: In N.Y., Gary Myers reports court-ordered mediation resumed yesterday in Minneapolis, and U.S. Magistrate Judge Arthur Boylan "reportedly asked the league to make a new proposal, which it agreed to." Whether the new proposal "addresses the players' concerns is obviously the issue." There are "many issues to settle but this has always been about the money" (N.Y. DAILY NEWS, 5/17). Michael Hausfeld, lead attorney for the retired players, said that the players "have a proposal from the league in hand," but a source indicated that it is "nothing more than a couple pages of bullet-points providing a framework." NFL.com's Albert Breer reports the "expectation of most on Monday was that the sides were headed for St. Louis and the 8th Circuit, though they will return to Boylan's chambers for more mediation" today. The mediation was "expected to last two days," and yesterday included four NFL owners, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell and Exec VP/Labor & General Counsel Jeff Pash and the NFLPA's Smith. Vikings LB Ben Leber was the "only player to appear." Chiefs LB Mike Vrabel, a plaintiff in the Brady v. NFL lawsuit, "was scheduled to, before his flight from Columbus was cancelled." Vrabel is "scheduled to make the trip on Tuesday morning for the second and final day of this part of the mediation" (NFL.com, 5/17).
WHOSE SIDE ARE YOU ON? In DC, Sally Jenkins writes, "Should you find yourself drifting to the side of the players in the NFL labor dispute, it doesn’t mean you’ve gone all communist." There is a "pattern forming." In the past week, "we’ve seen a new stadium proposal for the Minnesota Vikings that amounts to a bilking of taxpayers." A judge is "preparing to punish owners for cheating the players in negotiated TV deals," and waiters are suing a company co-founded by Cowboys Owner Jerry Jones for "withholding tips from $35-a-day concession workers." Jenkins: "If you had any lingering thoughts that the owners have been misunderstood or that the lockout isn’t their fault, recent events may have cured you of any sympathy with them" (WASHINGTON POST, 5/17).
In L.A., Lance Pugmire cites a source as saying that the NBPA "does not feel compelled to decertify before the owners institute a lockout, content to watch the NFL model unfold." The union yesterday confirmed Exec Dir Billy Hunter's memo to players, "in which he said the NBA is seeking a hard salary cap of $45 million per team with more clamps on guaranteed player contracts" (L.A. TIMES, 5/17).
PLACE YOUR BETS: In Las Vegas, Jon Ralston reported MLS Commissioner Don Garber last week "made calls to key Nevada lawmakers about an expansion team for Las Vegas, telling them he is supportive of the concept that needs approval from the Legislature for a taxing district near Mandalay Bay to fund a proposed arena/stadium/ballpark complex." Garber's move comes on the heels of Int'l Development Management President & CEO Chris Milam's purchase of the Triple-A PCL Las Vegas 51s and his "stated intentions to bring major league soccer and an NBA team to Las Vegas" (LASVEGASSUN.com, 5/15).
YOU'RE THE ONE THAT I WANT: In Charlotte, Ron Green Sr. writes under the header, "PGA Tour Desperately Needs A Star." There have been 19 different winners in 21 PGA Tour events this year, which "shows how much talent there is out there." But the Tour "needs someone who goes in as the favorite every time he plays, whose resume reads like fiction, whose score is being watched by everyone else in the field, who hits shots we never forget" (CHARLOTTE OBSERVER, 5/17). ESPN's Michael Wilbon said last weekend's The Players, in which 40-year-old K.J. Choi beat 44-year-old David Toms "wasn't exciting." Wilbon: "You have no young guns" ("PTI," ESPN, 5/16).
THE INSIDE JOB: The United Soccer Leagues yesterday announced that it "will operate the Major Indoor Soccer League beginning" with the '11-12 season. In the next few weeks, the MISL is "expected to announce additional franchises." In addition to the seven current MISL franchises, USL indoor teams from Norfolk, Rochester and Syracuse are "expected to join the MISL" (JSONLINE.com, 5/16). Chris Economides, Senior Dir of USL's pro leagues, will lead the MISL. Scheduling, competition and playoff format and rules for the MISL will be determined by the league’s BOG (K.C. STAR, 5/17).