SportsBusiness Daily — Sports Business Resources — your sports business news and information source. Learn More
Advanced
Home About Us Advertise With Us Marketplace/Classifieds College & University Program Subscribe/Trial My Account

Friday
July 18, 2008
Print This Issue


 
MOST VIEWED STORIES
View the top 20 stories
 
Recent Issues
Facilities & Venues

Judge Dismisses All But Two Claims In Marlins Ballpark Suit

Braman's Push For Public Vote On Proposed Marlins 
Ballpark Only Critical Issue Remaining In Lawsuit
Florida auto dealer Norman Braman's lawsuit over public financing for the proposed $515M Marlins ballpark was "nearly crippled Thursday when a judge dismissed all but two counts, with one critical issue hanging by a thread -- a push for a public vote on the stadium's financing," according to Charles Rabin of the MIAMI HERALD. Miami-Dade County (FL) Circuit Court Judge Jeri Beth Cohen dismissed Braman's claim that county commissioners "had no authority to reallocate $50[M] in voted-on bond money" to the ballpark. But the "biggest decision of all looms Friday," when Cohen is "expected to rule on Braman's quest for a public vote." The issue is the "centerpiece of Braman's fight," and arguments over the public vote were "lengthy and spirited in court Thursday." Marlins President David Samson said that if the Marlins "successfully fight the lawsuit, he expects stadium construction to begin by the end of the year." The other remaining count is "whether a sports facility serves a paramount public purpose -- a difficult issue for Braman to prove with only a single ruling going his way in the past 40 years." But Cohen's dismissals "didn't seem to deter Braman, who vowed to fight on -- for years if necessary." Braman's attorney, Bob Martinez, said, "It's just another issue on appeal. ... Norman is doing this as a matter of principle, and he's going to take this all the way to the Supreme Court" (MIAMI HERALD, 7/18).

POWER OF THE PEOPLE: In Ft. Lauderdale, Sarah Talalay reports Cohen Friday also is expected to rule "whether the financing for $3[B] in Miami projects needs to be put to a public referendum." Cohen said that she is "'sympathetic' to Braman's contention that it does." However, Cohen is "hampered because a Florida Supreme Court decision requiring a referendum when ad valorem taxes are used to pay off bonds on major public projects is being reconsidered, and she's unclear how it should be applied until it is final." The county and the Marlins Friday were intending to call witnesses to "show the stadium serves a 'paramount public purpose' to counter Braman's argument that they're using public dollars for a private enterprise" (South Florida SUN-SENTINEL, 7/18).

FISH OUT OF WATER: In Miami, Barry Jackson notes the Marlins this season are averaging 15,029 fans per home game at Dolphin Stadium, on pace to average fewer than 18,000 fans for the eighth time in the past 10 seasons. The Marlins' average attendance is the lowest in MLB, pulling in "more than 4,000 fewer fans per game" than the Pirates. But the Marlins, at 50-45, are just 1 1/2 games out of first place in the NL East, and the team's TV ratings are seventh highest in MLB this season. Samson: "Given our level of entertainment that is provided during games, both on and off the field, we certainly hoped our attendance would be higher." Samson said that the Marlins "spend $10[M] annually on advertising, sales and marketing, among the most in baseball." Jackson notes a Saturday night concert series at Dolphin Stadium "has boosted attendance, but some other promotions and creative gimmicks have not consistently attracted bigger crowds" (MIAMI HERALD, 7/18).

Related Stories By Company Related Stories By Sport
Samson Says Ballpark Delayed Until 2012
November 25, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

Suit May Force Delay For Marlins Ballpark
November 24, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

MLBPA Files Grievance Against Marlins
November 12, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

Financing Delay Could Slow Marlins Ballpark
October 23, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

Judge In Marlins Suit Delays Decision
September 23, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

Tribune Receives At Least Three Cubs Bids
December 2, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

Pro Sports See High Sales On Black Friday
December 2, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

Blue Jays Owner Ted Rogers Passes Away
December 2, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

Godfrey Named National Post Pres. & CEO
December 2, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

Pirates Increasing Latin American Efforts
December 2, 2008 : SportsBusiness Daily

ALSO IN THIS SECTION


A Publication of Street & Smith's Sports Group
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service
© 2008 Street & Smith's Sports Group
All Rights Reserved