Sidearm Sports adding Learfield schools Forty Under 40: Meredith Starkey Cartoon: Law and order league NFL licenses firm to market experiences Forty Under 40: Masters Champions Dinner D-League returns to ESPN Forty Under 40: Sashi Brown Forty Under 40: Chris Klein Richardson writes to fellow owners Arris connects with NASCAR
SBJ/November 19-25, 2012/In DepthPrint All
Premium seating continues to be a sales challenge as buyers give more scrutiny to their deals, the amenities they receive, and the return on their investment. To get a clearer picture of the premium landscape, SportsBusiness Journal facilities writer Don Muret asked four executives in the trenches to share their experiences. In a recent teleconference, they outlined how they have adapted to changing demands in their markets and how they’ve packaged perks and inventory to close the deal.
Q: Provide a breakdown of the premium seat mix in your buildings.
AL GUIDO, LEGENDS PREMIUM SALES: For the new 49ers stadium, we have three types of suites: 22 owners suites, all-inclusive from a food and beverage standpoint and [they include] all events. Those are sold out. All 20-year terms, $500,000 annually. Then we have our executive suites called the Tower Suites, around 108 total, and we’re 70 percent sold through on those. The Trophy Club Suites are our end zone suite product. It’s technically the same as an executive suite except it has a communal club space and all-inclusive food and beverage. From a club seat standpoint,
KRISTY FLETCHER, MAPLE LEAF SPORTS & ENTERTAINMENT: We have 142 suites. That number is broken down into 28 Platinum Suites — other venues might call them bunker suites. They have 10 tickets within the arena that go along with them. We have a product called Chairman’s Suites, where we converted 12 Platinum Suites into a large club, about 4,000 square feet, that accommodates 120 guests. We have 24 Theater Suites as well as 24 Loge Suites. They are comparable to our 200-level suites but in a less desirable location. We have 65 Executive Suites around the ring of the venue with 12 seats, with the ability to buy an additional eight tickets. The Chairman’s Suites are sold out. We have one open suite in our Executive Suite ring and are sitting on three open suites between our loge, theater and platinum. Four open suites out of 142. Our club seats are sold out.
CHARLIE FREEMAN, ORLANDO MAGIC: A lot of our agreements are three-, five-, seven- and 10-year deals, so being that we’re entering year three, we are pretty much sold through, 90 to 95 percent. We’ve got our Founders Suite Level and Presidents Suite Level, 32 on Founders, 28 on the Presidents. Sixty-eight loge boxes. Our Legends Suite is all-inclusive. I hate to say the word co-op suite, but it’s the ability to buy two, four, six tickets at a time. There are 150 tickets in each one of those super boxes. Then we have our courtside seats in our first five rows which have access to the Mercedes-Benz Lounge. All total, about 800 seats.
SCOTT O’CONNELL, MINNESOTA TWINS: We’re entering our fourth season at Target Field. There are 54 annual suites with 52 long-term contracts. Two of those we hold back for 10-game packages, a feeder system for annual suite holders. The vast majority of our suites are four-, seven- and 10-year deals, so I’ve got 19 suites out of 54 coming up for renewal. Behind home plate, the Champions Club consists of 413 seats. We’re through the renewal process on that, year to year. I’ve had eight seats that did not get renewed from last year. … I’ve got a waiting list of 57 names of people looking to get into the Champions Club, so it’s not going to be too difficult to find homes for those eight seats. Our Legends Club, which is a 3,000-seat wood-back chair location above the infield — we’re seeing a little bit more attrition in that area. I’ve got 142 seats available and I’m still looking at probably another 100 accounts yet to pull the trigger on coming back next year.
Q: How have these premium seat products changed over the years to meet market demand? Are there trends specific to your market?
FLETCHER: Right around the time of the recession, we had about $20 million coming up for renewal, our largest year ever. That’s when we sat back to look at our product mix. The first thing we did was take away bunker suites. At one time, we had 40. The perception of these suites [by customers] was no view of the ice, a little bit smaller, a little bit darker and I think they were losing flavor a little bit. So we took 12 bunkers and converted them into a very beautiful, almost super-premium space. At the time, it went against maybe what popular thought would be in that super premium
We sold out of that space … with two-year terms … and charged $100,000 for a pair for all events in the building. We actually did just sell them out again when the majority of those came up for renewal this past year. We’ve been very happy with that product. It’s allowed people to enter the super premium market without having to buy a full suite. You could buy two, four, six tickets, whatever worked for your business. It was a great networking tool; we saw huge benefit in that. Someone who bought in owns a Porsche dealership and has sold three or four cars to other members. It’s allowed us to really get to know the clients well, understand what their business needs are and bring like-minded clients together.
And lastly, instead of cutting back on our sales force and service, we added staff at a time when I think a lot of people were cutting back. In the long run, it took us from having at our peak 18 unsold suites to four.
O’CONNELL: We made some adjustments on the fly as the ballpark was built. We initially had plans to put in 60 annual suites, but as the recession kicked in, in the midst of our selling process, we decided to turn a few annual suites into party suites. We took the six suites furthest down the third-base line and turned them into two 50-person Skyline Suites with a view of downtown Minneapolis. They have been a great vehicle for us because we have nothing [else] of that size to handle a large group. We have a pocket door between the two which can make it accessible for up to 100 people. I think we were smart enough to recognize when the recession hit that this was something that we were going to end up doing eventually, let’s do it now and take care of our needs initially. We have the MLB All-Star Game [in 2014], something we had an inkling about for quite some time. So that’s why we went to market with a four-year lease instead of three years. We timed it so these leases would expire at the time of the All-Star Game. We also have the Vikings to contend with as their new facility is coming online. They will come to market with 100 to 150 suites, so a lot of what happens [with us] will depend on how good of a product we have got on the field.
FREEMAN: We do a lot of research and focus groups and have met with all of our premium seat holders. The things we’re hearing that are very successful is that they like our all-inclusive products. In particular, the Legends Suite and our courtside seats. The all-inclusive is something that people like, that turnkey approach where they can give tickets to clients. So we’re looking at that potentially for our loge product and other spaces in the building. We continue to try to focus on ways we can enhance, whether it’s amenities, food offerings. As of right now, we’re in that due diligence phase to try and understand what the market may dictate in the future.
GUIDO: I think the NFL in general has seen a shift to yard-line club seats. We’ve seen a shift where the premium product on the 100 level and the mezzanine level becomes a price reduction for a club seat. We do our best to limit end zone inventory from a premium standpoint. It really just doesn’t have a lot of cachet, so instead of creating multiple products, we went with a less-is-more approach with just suites and clubs. You have to take a hard look at value proposition. … We didn’t want to compete with ourselves by having a four- or eight-person loge box go up against a 16-person suite. We just figured, let’s take a look at our 16-person suite price and determine what the value proposition will be, because the objection on number of people in a suite wasn’t really something we were hearing that much.
Another concept starting to grow legs is communal spaces for suite owners, an extension of a tailgate in a premium space. For us, 22 suites with a 22,000-square-foot club, with all-inclusive food and beverage, becomes a who’s who of the marketplace.
Q: What are your customers asking for that may be different than when you first took those products to market, everything from amenities to experiences? What are they asking you for before they sign on the dotted line?
O’CONNELL: As we get into this process, some of the things we’re trying to come forward with, [for example], each suite received two parking spots. We’re now going to renovate that into more of a valet parking spot associated with our
Photo by:Minnesota Twins
FREEMAN: We do some similar things on the event side to stay engaged. We have our summer league every year where we invite folks into the arena. We also do a fantasy camp for all of our suite holders, a competition between our Founders Level and our Presidents Level. We have our coaches and players out there. We also have a premium golf tournament. The other thing we’re exploring is our B-to-B platform and how we can help our clients, both our corporate partners, as well as our premium customers, together to help create business opportunities.
FLETCHER: In Toronto, we just came off another $20 million renewal. We have our standard package with a trip to the Masters. There is enough exclusivity that it will push a renewal. A lot of things we were hearing over the past 12 months is a lot of our suite holders are looking for measurement tools. So, what can we do to help them track their inventory when they’re getting 150 events a year and you have one suite administrator trying to manage all the inventory? We implemented Spotlight [software management] this year. Another thing we hear a lot is they really do want the VIP exclusive access to our athletes, to our coaches, anything really behind the scenes that we can offer them or their clients.
Our single-most successful renewal tool is the Adopt-a-Suite program. We have become our own secondary ticket market. We have 150 events in our building, often too many for suite holders. We take back their unused inventory and try to resell it for them. … So when it comes time to renew their suites and we’re putting a fairly large number in front of them, we can say, yes, however, we were able to help subsidize whatever portion it is. It’s not a revenue driver for us. We’ll take a 15 percent cut of the fee and give 85 percent to the suite holders. If I can keep five to 10 suite holders, it’s really invaluable to us.
Photo by:San Francisco 49ers
Q: What do you think the suite of the future will look like 10 to 20 years from now?
FLETCHER: It’s going to incorporate a lot more technology than what your average suite is now, more fan focused. I think we’d all love to get to a point where you have one application that would allow your suite holder to order food, contact their hostess or purchase additional tickets for an upcoming game. We invested in more boardroom space to use their suite as more of an extension of their office.
FREEMAN: I think what’s important for all the buildings is that you remain flexible based on demand. So if the
Photo by:Orlando Magic
O’CONNELL: You’re going to find suite owners looking for more of a return on their investment. That’s nothing new, but I think as we move forward into the future, it is paramount part to owning a suite. They’re going to have more of a marketing scene in their suites. I’ve got [high-end countertop maker] Cambria in this facility that utilizes their suite on a pretty regular basis during the offseason and during the regular season to use it as an opportunity to [sell] their wares. I think you’re going to find it’s not just a box for a game; it’s an extension of their business and they need to use it more for that than just entertaining.
GUIDO: It’s so important when you’re designing a new building to think about the future of your premium areas and what your sell-through rates are as you’re going through the process of selling the building. As Charlie said, we have spent a ton of time on areas that could easily convert to club spaces. The other thing, location has become extremely important from a suite perspective. People like being outdoors and closer to the field of play. The last part, we are in a software world now. Can I run my tablet? Can I get replays? Can I order food? Can I change the lighting? Can I run PowerPoints off my suite? What type of flexibility do you have in technology? That to me is the future of the premium seat world.
Sports facility developers are always thinking of new ways to create the ultimate VIP experience as premium customers demand more than the standard amenities of a suite and a club seat. Event-level suites and clubs fulfill those needs.
These high-end spaces cross paths with players walking to and from locker rooms, such as at Cowboys Stadium and Amway Center, and taking their cuts in batting cages at Marlins Park and Nationals Park. One sideline field-level club at MetLife Stadium provides members with exclusive access to coaches’ postgame news conferences.
Planned Gridiron Club, Davis Wade Stadium.
Rendering by:360 Architecture
Now, the concept is trickling down to the college level. At Mississippi State, 360 Architecture has designed the Gridiron Club at Davis Wade Stadium, part of a $75 million expansion set to open in 2014. Season-ticket holders, regardless of seat location, can buy memberships to a field-level club in the north end zone. The cost is $750, a separate fee from season tickets, with room in the club for 700 people. At any point before and during the game, club members can walk down to the lounge, buy a drink and walk outside to view the action from a platform slightly above field level.
“It’s a visceral experience where they actually come into the coaches and athletes’ world,” said Nate Appleman, the project’s principal designer with 360 Architecture. “In a sense, we’re pulling the field into the club.”
One big happy family
Entertaining guests in a traditional suite is no longer restricted to being isolated in a private box with catered food and drink.
Taking a cue from European soccer stadiums, more North American sports facilities are developing smaller suites that
Livestrong Signature Suites, Shield Club.
The Commissioner’s Club and its $1 million-a-year suites at MetLife Stadium, home of the Jets and Giants, and Livestrong Sporting Park’s Signature Suites, the first skyboxes to sell out at the MLS facility, are two examples.
The design trend “breaks the boundaries” of the suite experience by forging a connection with skybox owners and their neighbors down the hall, said Brian Mirakian, an associate principal with Populous, Livestrong Park’s architect.
Outside looking in
The success of Champions Square, an outdoor tailgate zone next to the Mercedes-Benz Superdome, has sports architect AECOM pitching other NFL teams on how to cash in on pregame spaces without having to share revenue with other teams.
In New Orleans, where AECOM designed the dome’s post-Katrina upgrades, the Saints, stadium manager SMG and concessionaire Centerplate are stakeholders in Club 44, a premium indoor lounge and an extension of Champions Square
Club 44, Mercedes-Benz Superdome.
Photo by:Pat Garin
The square itself is a public space; those who desire a higher-end pregame experience can buy a ticket for Club 44, a retrofit of an old Macy’s department store. Originally, access was sold as an all-inclusive ticket for $45 that covered all-you-can-eat food and drink. This year, however, the club rolled back the price of the ticket to $10, which covers one gratis drink. All other food and drink purchases are on a cash basis.
In Seattle, AECOM, the architect of CenturyLink Field, is in talks with the Seahawks for developing a similar pop-up exterior tailgate zone.
“The question I’m asking teams is what is the end goal?” said AECOM principal Jon Niemuth. “Suites are the greatest cost [for teams to build]. Where else can you generate hospitality-related revenue with the least amount of cost?”
Downsizing to a perfect fit
Regardless of the description, teams are transforming unsold suites into smaller sections of premium seats supported by a group dining space. In some cases, they are upgrading club seats and regular seats with no amenities into an all-inclusive product to meet the needs of small businesses and individual ticket buyers.
Madison Square Garden, Xcel Energy Center and Bridgestone Arena are three recent examples of arenas now marketing two-, four- and six-seat packages in their facilities. In Nashville, the Predators created the 501 Club on the club level,
501 Club, Bridgestone Arena.
Photo by:Nashville Predators
At MSG, the new 174-seat Madison Club, situated at stage end in the lower bowl, is sold as a sports-only product, covering Rangers, Knicks, college basketball, boxing and tennis. Prices start at $42,500 a seat per year. The midpriced premium seats cater to smaller companies that still wish to entertain clients without spending six figures annually to buy a suite.
In St. Paul, the Minnesota Wild saw the need to develop a midpriced premium product 12 years after opening its arena. Before this season, team officials had nothing to offer between a suite and a club seat. The 24 new, four-person terrace loge boxes are in the arena’s west end. The all-inclusive loges, priced at $48,000 to $53,000 annually, cover tickets to all Wild games and most other events.
It’s the altitude
The upper deck has typically posed challenges for teams to consistently fill in their buildings and the same is true for upper suite levels. Clubs with empty inventory at the highest point of premium seating are making adjustments to occupy those spaces.
At the Palace of Auburn Hills, the Detroit Pistons eliminated 16 suites on the penthouse level to develop Club 300, a flexible group space with 192 fixed seats and standing room for 108 on the arena’s third level. Early in the season, officials are testing the club as an all-inclusive dining option for NBA games and other events to get feedback from
Club 300, Palace of Auburn Hills.
Photo by:Detroit Pistons / Dan Lippitt
In general, Club 300 tickets cost $30 to $100 depending on the event and the food and drink package, said Chris Quinn, the Pistons’ vice president of business development and premium seating. For the Super Bowl, club patrons can watch the Pistons game and hang around afterward to watch the NFL title game on 16 televisions inside the space. Ticket prices and the menu have not been set but will probably be a little more than $100, Quinn said. The same is true for Maroon 5, with tickets about $250 per couple for a buffet dinner, a rose and a glass of champagne.
In Dallas, Center Operating Co., manager of American Airlines Center, developed the new SeasonPass program that is tied to 20 skyboxes that had been reserved for single-game sales. Those suites now carry one-year deals with tickets to Mavericks and Stars games only, a departure from the standard multiyear terms typically required. The cost is $125,000 for the season; those suites were previously $225,000 a year for all events, with a three-year commitment.