Menu
Labor and Agents

NFL, union still fighting workers' comp battle

The NFL and the players union’s battle over workers’ compensation, one of the last unresolved issues from the spring and summer of labor discontent, spilled into a Louisiana court last week, with the NFLPA contending that the league has no say in where players can file such claims, even if their contracts stipulate otherwise.

The move coincided with increased public pressure on the NFLPA from Congress to agree to HGH testing, an issue the league had thought was settled with the Aug. 4 ratification of the new 10-year collective-bargaining agreement.

The one issue the league knew was unresolved on that day was the increasingly contentious question of where players can file workers’ compensation claims. Most wish to file in generous California, while teams want them to file in their team’s home state.

The NFL is suing the NFLPA and eight former Saints players to enforce an Aug. 23 arbitrator’s decision that the players must revoke their claims in California and refile in Louisiana because their contracts specifically called on them to file in the Southern state.

But the NFLPA contends that even if their contracts called for them to file in the Saints’ home state, and even if the CBA in effect at the time allowed for this, it is irrelevant.

“The California Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board has ruled that any provision of an employment agreement between an NFL Player and Club that purports to limit the NFL Player’s ability to pursue workers’ compensation benefits in California is void and unenforceable,” the NFLPA said in a court brief last week.

California has one of the country’s most generous systems, allowing anyone who has physically done business in the state to file a claim for injury, and with no sunset provision. The Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board has ruled that NFL players who have competed in a game in the state, even if they were not directly injured in that contest, can file a claim.

It is one reason the reconstituted Arena Football League chose not to put a team in California. Several teams, including the Washington Redskins and New York Jets, have recently fought efforts by players to file in California, according to the NFLPA brief.

The Saints players all had clauses in their contracts stating if they were to file for workers’ compensation, it had to be in Louisiana. Nevertheless, they filed in California, and the NFL took the case to an arbitrator.

Irwin Kishner, a lawyer with Herrick Feinstein who wrote a legal article in 2010 on why California’s workers’ compensation system is a problem for sports leagues, said he sides with the NFL in this case.

“There were two well-represented parties that freely executed a contract,” he said. “It is not saying you can’t avail yourself of California, the contract just says you [choose to] avail yourself of Louisiana.”

Kishner still expects the case to go far, perhaps even to the Supreme Court to decide on the constitutional merits of how California’s workers’ compensation system purports to have a say over contracts in other states.

The NFLPA in its brief argued that the Supreme Court has ruled that an employee cannot negotiate down their rights in a contract, and so the provisions are unenforceable.

As a subtext to the case, it is the first legal battle between the NFL and NFLPA since the new CBA, and thus is out of Judge David Doty’s court in Minnesota.

Doty, as part of the 1993 antitrust settlement that resulted in the CBA that ran through March 2011, oversaw labor relations between the two sides. Any dispute went to a special master, and then on appeal to Doty, whom the league viewed as being overly player friendly.

The new CBA, signed on Aug. 4, eliminated Doty’s role. Twenty days later the NFL filed the lawsuit against the players and NFLPA in the Louisiana court.

The NFLPA is represented by Dewey & LeBoeuf. Adams and Reese, a local New Orleans firm, submitted the NFL complaint.

The case is named New Orleans Saints, L.L.C. et al v. Cleeland. Cam Cleeland is one of the eight former players.


SBJ Morning Buzzcast: March 25, 2024

NFL meeting preview; MLB's opening week ad effort and remembering Peter Angelos.

Big Get Jay Wright, March Madness is upon us and ESPN locks up CFP

On this week’s pod, our Big Get is CBS Sports college basketball analyst Jay Wright. The NCAA Championship-winning coach shares his insight with SBJ’s Austin Karp on key hoops issues and why being well dressed is an important part of his success. Also on the show, Poynter Institute senior writer Tom Jones shares who he has up and who is down in sports media. Later, SBJ’s Ben Portnoy talks the latest on ESPN’s CFP extension and who CBS, TNT Sports and ESPN need to make deep runs in the men’s and women's NCAA basketball tournaments.

SBJ I Factor: Nana-Yaw Asamoah

SBJ I Factor features an interview with AMB Sports and Entertainment Chief Commercial Office Nana-Yaw Asamoah. Asamoah, who moved over to AMBSE last year after 14 years at the NFL, talks with SBJ’s Ben Fischer about how his role model parents and older sisters pushed him to shrive, how the power of lifelong learning fuels successful people, and why AMBSE was an opportunity he could not pass up. Asamoah is 2021 SBJ Forty Under 40 honoree. SBJ I Factor is a monthly podcast offering interviews with sports executives who have been recipients of one of the magazine’s awards.

Shareable URL copied to clipboard!

https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Journal/Issues/2011/10/31/Labor-and-Agents/NFL-workers-comp.aspx

Sorry, something went wrong with the copy but here is the link for you.

https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Journal/Issues/2011/10/31/Labor-and-Agents/NFL-workers-comp.aspx

CLOSE