SBJ/August 1-7, 2011/In DepthPrint All
Plenty of teams and leagues remain vexed by domain names and cyber squatting, but changes coming in 2012 could bring greater clarity to the Web.
Long after the Internet came to be, domain squabbles remain an issue. In Dallas alone, all four big league franchises have no control over basic derivations of their identities. Cowboys.com won’t take you to the NFL team’s site, mavericks.com doesn’t assist fans to the NBA champs’ page, stars.com isn’t an NHL franchise domain, and rangers.com is home to a site promoting media architecture rather than the American League champions.
Such long-standing conflicts still cause ample heartburn, though leagues and teams say Google, Bing and other search engines have mitigated those concerns in recent years. The more intriguing question centers on what comes after the dot in the dot-coms.
In the tricky world of domain names, fans putting mavericks.com or stars.com into their browser won’t be calling up the home of the NBA champs or the NHL club.
At present, there are 22 approved top-level domains, the familiar suffixes such as dot-com, dot-org and dot-net. The new system, long-discussed and oft-delayed, will give leagues, teams and everyone else with the will and the wallet a chance to pick what follows the first part of a Web address.
As an example, the Philadelphia Phillies could gain control of a dot-phillies top-level domain, steering fans, sponsors and everyone else to a name that makes it clear what the brand is and who controls it.
And there is much more to the idea than just the name. Any organization, sports or otherwise, in charge of its top-level domain could then sell or give sponsors, fans, employees and others the right to use the suffix, entirely at their discretion.
Josh Bourne, managing partner at domain-name strategy consultant FairWinds Partners, whose clients include Nike, said teams and leagues will first view the additional suffixes from a defensive position. That is, they will want to determine how to prevent others from squatting or subverting their identities.
Unlike most companies, though, there is a potential payoff in sports, where customers could be willing to pay for a piece of a top-level domain name. For example, the Chicago Blackhawks could offer fans the chance to have an email address attached to what the franchise controls, such as blackhawks.nhl. By selling that off to each fan for $50 or $100 per year, some teams could quickly offset the application fee.
“My gut is they haven’t taken seriously enough the revenue side because they’re mainly looking at this from an intellectual property point of view rather than a business point of view,” Bourne said. “There’s a big revenue opportunity here.”
At the same time, there’s great expense. Applying for a top-level domain name costs $185,000, and requires wading through a 300-page set of rules and winning approval as part of an assessment expected to take as long as a full year. Applications can be submitted through April 2012. If successful, managing the top-level domain name could cost hundreds of thousands of dollars more each year, according to ICANN.
ICANN points to the cost and lengthy application period as deterrents to squatting. Still, uncertainty looms.
How, after all, might the dot-football, dot-baseball or dot-sports suffix be awarded, if it ever is? And how many top-level domain names are necessary? Would nike.nike be enough, or would the sneaker giant want nike.swoosh and nike.justdoit, as well?
With top-level domain name applications to be considered for three months next year and then awarded a year later, there is intense pressure on all companies, sports or otherwise, to get it right. That’s because it may be five to 10 years before more are awarded beyond this first round, Bourne said.
So will sports properties pony up for the additional domain names?
Bob Bowman, president and CEO of MLB Advanced Media, said the trend is clearly away from domain names and their importance because of search engines, apps and so on. “In terms of how people are going to access content, I think they’re less and less important,” he said. “In terms of where activity is going to be because of [new suffixes], they’re going to be more and more important.”
MLBAM controls 3,500 domain names related to the sport and its teams. Of the so-called optimal domain names — yankees.com, cubs.com, etc. — MLBAM has rights to 24 of them. Giants.com is controlled by the NFL team of the same name, with the rest held by other entities beyond baseball (Athletics, Rangers, Rays, Rockies and Twins).
And don’t expect a big move at the Southeastern Conference, where secsports.com and secdigitalnetwork.com are home to football rather than financial traders.
“There’s always going to be someone else who has a business or an entity that’s got similar letters to you,” said Charlie Hussey, the SEC’s assistant commissioner for marketing and licensing. “It’s a balance of trying to use a more complete term. It’s certainly easier now to find what you’re looking for. … We’re comfortable with what we’ve got.”
Plenty of teams and leagues are willing to let some names go, forsaking a big payday to a squatter or someone who has a legitimate claim to the name and is unlikely to let it go. In other cases, a fan could be persuaded to give up a domain name by being granted access through an interview for a blog site or with premium seats to a game or championship.
Other situations still require legal action. “If they’re using it inappropriately, you do have to go after it still,” said Mark Passler, an intellectual property attorney at Akerman Senterfitt whose clients have included the Miami Dolphins, Florida Panthers and the PGA Tour. “You have to go after it if somebody’s using something inappropriately and it looks like somehow you’re endorsing them.”
Erik Spanberg writes for the Charlotte Business Journal, an affiliated publication.
Even in its relative infancy, social media has already proved itself to be an effective tool to boost fan interaction, forge connections between teams and leagues and their fans, sell tickets and merchandise, and help drive TV viewership.
But there remains nothing close to a one-size-fits-all approach for effectively leveraging social media. Rather, many different strategies have been pursued by sports properties, often in concert with traditional media extensions.
What follows is a snapshot of 20 effective uses of social media within sports over the past year, from properties to personalities, illustrating some of the ways the industry is finding traction.
SnappyTV gets the picture
If Mike Folgner, chief executive of San Francisco-based startup SnappyTV, gets his way, “snap” will be a social media verb in the same vein as tweet.
“Quite simply, the best ad for watching a game is the game itself,” Folgner said. “Our technology helps make that happen.”
A test conducted in May with Tennis Channel for the French Open generated more than 2 million views of snapped video clips. One clip, in which a ballboy accidentally interfered with a point during an Andy Murray match, generated more than 400,000 video views through SnappyTV. The company is now aggressively targeting college football networks for additional deployments, and is seeking to develop an advertising-based revenue model around the snapped clips.
“We’ve got great evidence that we can drive tune-in,” Folgner said. “So we believe we’re resonating with rights holders and can begin to grow very quickly.”
Cleveland Indians Social Media Suite
The Cleveland Indians wanted to participate in the local social media conversation around the team rather than just be bystanders. As opposed to simply credentialing bloggers and other active social media participants with press box access, the club last year opened the Social Media Deck in the bleachers of Progressive Field. Seating 10, outfitted with wireless Internet access, and sponsored by Time Warner Cable, the section helped build good will for a club coming off a 97-loss season.
The suite at Progressive Field has built a waiting list of more than 200 people.
The Indians built upon that success this season by expanding the Social Media Deck into a 12-seat luxury suite at the ballpark. Still administered on an invitation-only basis, the Social Media Suite this season has built a waiting list of more than 200 people and is almost fully subscribed for the rest of the season. The move comes in concert with several senior club executives, including team President Mark Shapiro, activating Twitter accounts.
“This has given us a tangible platform to show our commitment to the social media space,” said Curtis Danburg, Indians senior director of communications. “We’re creating new brand ambassadors who are then going out and talking about the Indians experience and are in essence spreading our message. It’s hard to fully quantify the effects of that, but we know there’s been incremental lift [in ticket sales and attendance].”
MLB’s All-Star performance
MLB’s All-Star fan voting process is already the largest of its type in pro sports. But balloting this year soared to a record 32.5 million, 36 percent above the prior mark of 23.9 million ballots set in 2009, thanks in part to an aggressive Twitter hashtagging effort concentrated on several key positional races.
The All-Star Game social media blitz continued during the July 11 Home Run Derby during which 23 players, including Toronto slugger and Derby participant Jose Bautista, tweeted and posted to Facebook during the event under the coordinated hashtag of #HRDerby. Those 23 players collectively gained more than 121,000 new Twitter followers in the 18 hours following the event, and more than 18,000 mentions back to their accounts. The event peaked at 4,995 tweets per second, good for the eighth-highest such figure in Twitter’s five-year history.
MLB encouraged player tweets and Facebook posts, even setting up social media stations near the Chase Field dugouts.
“It’s one thing to have a TV analyst talk about how a David Ortiz did at the plate in that last round,” said Andrew Patterson, MLBAM manager of new media. “But to have Ortiz himself go right on Twitter and do it, that’s very compelling.”
Twackle measures up
Octagon Digital began Twackle in early 2009 as a consumer-facing Twitter aggregation engine. It has since morphed into a social media-powered news analytics engine aimed primarily at publishers and other business-to-business clients. Twackle now primarily tracks which news stories are shared the most on Twitter, and, in turn, are most likely to go truly viral.
With a variety of analytics that include heat maps, geographic clusters and detailed sharing patterns, Octagon Digital
“We’re basically train spotting,” said Jim DeLorenzo, Octagon Digital vice president. “But we now have tools in place where content can be measured and evaluated in real time.”
Red Sox ask for advice
Construction of the master MLB schedule is a complex affair that involves months of work and endless compromise to balance many competing interests. But the Boston Red Sox this spring, during the playoff run of the neighboring Bruins, went to Twitter and Facebook to conduct real-time crowdsourcing about a game time change under consideration for June 4.
The polling initiative came as part of a heightened use of Twitter overall by the Red Sox during games, such as Tweet Your Seat merchandise giveaways and Tweet Your Tunes, in which fans request songs to be played in the ballpark during rain delays.
Turner buddies up to fans
Through services like NASCAR.com’s RaceBuddy and TNT’s Overtime, Turner uses social media applications as a companion to its broadcasts. These applications use alternate camera angles and chat rooms to attract online viewers while Turner Sports’ events are being telecast.
“There’s a lot of social activity happening along a given sporting event and we wanted to capture that,” said Matt
Hong pointed to RaceBuddy as an example. Turner saw TV ratings for its six races in 2011 jump for the first time in three years, averaging 5.125 million viewers. It also saw online activity around RaceBuddy increase. The social media platform saw a 76 percent increase in viewership, averaging 936,000 streams per race.
— John Ourand
Women’s World Cup sets mark
The current record for most tweets per second isn’t held by the Super Bowl, World Series, NBA or NHL finals, or even the men’s World Cup, but rather the July 17 Women’s World Cup final between the U.S. and Japan.
The final set a record for tweets.
But unlike many other league-coordinated social media efforts, the Women’s World Cup frenzy on Twitter was essentially all organic and fan-driven. Even U.S. President Barack Obama tweeted 13 times during the match. The match’s 7,196 tweets per second beat out not only every other sporting event in tweet volume, but other major news events such as the Japan earthquake and the death of Osama bin Laden.
Individual stars for the U.S. team saw their own social media lift, as well. Goalie Hope Solo entered the tournament in late June with fewer than 10,000 followers. She now has more than 244,000.
JetBlue flies with Twitter
JetBlue Airways, only 12 years old, is an airline born in the digital age. It also is by far the most followed airline on Twitter, with more than 1.6 million followers, and is widely praised as one of the most active consumer brands of any type in social media.
Social media is a prime component of activating its sports partnerships, including ones with the New York Jets,
In January, JetBlue Chief Executive Dave Barger conducted a Twitter challenge with Doug Parker, his counterpart at US Airways and a Pittsburgh Steelers sponsor, over the AFC Championship Game. After some friendly back-and-forth on Twitter and a Pittsburgh victory, Barger made good on his bet and posted a picture of himself wearing a Steelers jersey and US Airways hat.
“This is all about having a direct dialogue with our customers,” said Morgan Johnston, JetBlue manager of corporate communications and head of the company’s social media efforts. “Sports is obviously a big part of our marketing efforts, and our customers are clearly passionate about sports. So that is an important part of the conversation, too.”
This is Mission Control
The concept behind the New Jersey Devils’ “Mission Control,” a social media hub housed within the club’s Prudential Center home, is strikingly simple: Who better to engage the club’s fans on social media than the fans themselves?
Fans volunteer to staff the New Jersey Devils’ social media hub.
Inspired by other brands, such as Dell and Gatorade, that have built similar on-site social media centers, Mission Control is staffed about six hours a day during the offseason, and as long as 12 hours on game days. Since Mission Control launched in February, the Devils’ Facebook following has nearly doubled to more than 192,000 fans, and the Twitter audience has grown to more than 28,000 followers. Two ticket promotions that were run through Mission Control sold more than 850 tickets and generated nearly $18,000 in incremental gross revenue.
Among the elements under exploration for Mission Control during the next hockey season are an expansion into location-based social media and daily online deals for tickets and merchandise.
“This new social media platform gives our fans the opportunity to get even more deeply invested in the team they love,” said Devils owner Jeff Vanderbeek.
ESPN goes virtual
It wasn’t much of a surprise when ESPN launched its second Farmville-style game last month. “Sports Bar” feels a lot like its first social media game, “College Town.”
ESPN executives say the performance of “College Town,” in which users build virtual campuses, convinced them that
“‘College Town’ has been our biggest social media business success to date,” said Patrick Stiegman, ESPN.com’s vice president and editor-in-chief. “We’ve seen a lot of stickiness with fans. And they’ve spent a fair amount of money to purchase upgrades.”
ESPN launched “College Town” in September 2010 and says more than 582,000 monthly users still are logging in to play. Up to 60,000 people still interact with the game every day. ESPN has seen more than 7 million total downloads, with users spending about 70 minutes per session.
“Activity has leveled out a bit,” Stiegman said. “But the amount of money people are spending on it is increasing.”
— John Ourand
NBA players hold court
The NBA is well-known for its strong social media position within the sports industry, with a combined Facebook and Twitter following of more than 23 million at the league level. The NBA conducts daily social media strategy sessions and is as aggressive as anybody in the space.
Shaquille O’Neal (see related item) staged an early foothold on Twitter and remains a force there. But he is joined by a legion of other current megastars, including Orlando’s Dwight Howard, Miami’s LeBron James and Dwyane Wade, New York’s Carmelo Anthony, Boston’s Paul Pierce and Phoenix’s Steve Nash, among many others.
NBA-related entities occupy 10 slots in the 500 most-followed Twitter accounts, far more than any other sports property.
Social Bowl XLV
Super Bowl XLV this past February quickly became known in some circles as the Social Bowl, as many of the game’s advertisers debuted their spots and conducted supplemental contests and fan activities on Twitter and Facebook.
The shift dramatically changed the time-honored playbook of corporate marketing in and around the game, and
Volkswagen’s ad went viral before the Super Bowl.
Among the Super Bowl advertisers most active on social media were Volks-wagen, which leaked its Star Wars-inspired ad several days before the game and saw it go viral with more than 12 million views by Super Bowl Sunday; and Lipton Brisk, whose animated ad featuring Eminem pushed viewers to the company’s Facebook page. There, consumers found additional videos, and could submit their own stories and enter to win an Xbox 360.
Shaq touts his future
Legendary NBA center Shaquille O’Neal often has had a keen sense of the moment, and he showed it again in June when he announced his retirement from the league. O’Neal did the customary press conference, but he first broke his news through Tout.com, a startup, real-time video messaging service.
O’Neal’s 15-second retirement video on Tout.com gained more than 500,000 views in the first three hours after it was posted, and he has since made numerous additional videos for the platform. Tout remains in an early developmental stage, but has raised $2 million in venture capital funding.
Dana White gets punchy
UFC President Dana White is widely known as a brutally candid, outspoken executive. Those traits have lent themselves powerfully to social media, where the league has more than 6 million fans on Facebook, and White himself has 1.5 million Twitter followers.
Like many other sports entities, the UFC employs help from social media consultants, and the UFC itself works with
The UFC president is known to hit back via Twitter.
But the centerpiece of the social media initiatives is White himself, who has been known to use his Twitter following to excoriate high-ranking executives such as EA Sports President Peter Moore and respond to some fan questions with a terse, “Total BS.”
The approach at once fits the graphic, confrontational nature of the sport and removes any sort of public relations veneer.
NHL heats up Winter Classic
The NHL for years has boasted a fan base younger and more technologically adept than many other properties, making its full-throttle entry into social media over the past several years a natural extension of what had already been happening on its various digital platforms.
Fans were asked to register at the league’s Facebook page. During the game, names of selected winners would appear on the TV screen. Those fans would then receive phone calls from NHL staffers with questions related to the Winter Classic game. Prizes including a Honda CR-Z and a trip to the NHL All-Star Game were awarded for correct answers.
The effort helped boost awareness and usage of the NHL’s Facebook page, now with more than 1.7 million fans. The game on TV also grew to an average audience of 4.5 million viewers, the largest draw for a regular-season NHL game since 1975, though a rain-delayed shift to a prime-time window also played a key role.
Speed slows down for questions
Many networks in recent months have sought to boost interaction between broadcasters and fans during telecasts, such as answering questions on air submitted via Twitter and Facebook. Speed is the latest to pursue such a strategy, employing the Speed Social Tracker for the Sprint All-Star Race in May at Charlotte.
The effort involved a social media dashboard featuring more than 20 network personalities answering fan questions,
Coordinated under several hashtags, including #sprintallstar and #speedQA, the dashboard also pooled all other driver and fan comments on the event. The Speed Social Tracker generated more than 67,000 views on the day of the race, and helped boost Speed’s Facebook page by 54 percent during the month.
Ratings for the race on Speed grew 1 percent overall, and by 58 percent among men ages 18-34, helping amplify a broader resurgence for the sport on TV.
Shaun White works some corporate magic
Champion snowboarder Shaun White appeals strongly to a younger demographic fully engaged with social media.
The action sports star has found ways to give exposure to his many sponsors..
Companies such as Oakley, Stride and BF Goodrich are given exposure on his social media channels without crossing over into blatant and constant commercialism.
During a recent promotional trip to New York, White gave away free Oakley sunglasses to Twitter and Facebook followers who came to the company store armed with a code word.
EA’s gaming turns social
There’s little debate in the industry that gaming is a red-hot segment of social media. Until recently, the space has been dominated by smaller entities, many of which did not have any licensed intellectual property within their games. But now the major players are taking notice.
EA Sports, after several initial efforts around Facebook-based gaming, is applying a broad social media element to
The effort seeks to blend all the interaction of social media with a full-featured gaming experience not possible on Facebook.
He’s now retired from cycling competition and probably will always be under suspicion that he used performance enhancers during his run of seven straight Tour de France titles. But few current or former athletes aside from Shaquille O’Neal have adopted social media as early and readily as Lance Armstrong.
After a most recent set of doping allegations in May on “60 Minutes” from former teammate Tyler Hamilton, Armstrong posted on Facebook, “20+ year career. 500 drug controls worldwide, in and out of competition. Never a failed test. I rest my case.”
My tenant hits .300
In the lower reaches of affiliated and independent minor league baseball, housing can sometimes be a big challenge for players. With call-ups, trades, injuries and outright releases all constant threats, signing leases for rental property can be a difficult proposition for players earning minimal salaries.
For many collegiate summer baseball leagues, where the only income for players is typically outside odd jobs, the
GARY SOUTH SHORE RAILCATS
Host families pose with their RailCats players.
As result, many individual clubs and leagues have successfully turned to Facebook to find host families to provide places for players to stay for the summer, relying on the viral nature of the platform and the ability to reach fans where they are spending significant time as opposed to more static forms of outreach.
The Gary (Ind.) South Shore RailCats of the independent Northern League were one team that recently went to Facebook, under the front of its mascot Rusty, to find player housing from local fans.