From The Executive Editor: Making waves Cartoon: Holiday let-down Sutton Impact: Books to lead by Cartoon: An NFL Christmas Carol From The Executive Editor: Most Influential Lessons to tomorrow’s executives From The Executive Editor: CFP progress Cartoon: Detour From the Field of Sports Collectibles Space: The next frontier in sponsorship?
SBJ/June 12 - 18, 2006/Opinion
Leave baseball history in the past
Published June 12, 2006
One thing that separates baseball from other sports in my mind is its historical grounding. Baseball has eras. Baseball has periods.
This is a fact that should influence Major League Baseball’s response to what has become a media-driven steroids controversy. I say media-driven because fans just don’t care about this issue; you can tell that from the fact that real baseball news drives out steroid news once the season starts. That was the case last year and will be the case this year, despite Barry Bonds’ home-run record chase. Bonds will make history this year and he will deserve every possible accolade.
I hope the commissioner’s office realizes that baseball is history and history is context and one can’t change history. Major League Baseball and the players union made their first mistake on this matter by letting Congress dictate to them. I see nothing wrong with obeying the subpoenas, then telling those grandstanding politicians that baseball would be happy to implement the same drug-testing policy that’s in place for Congress. (FYI: There is no drug-testing policy for Congress).
The bottom line is that there was a steroids era in baseball, that era is part of baseball’s history, a lot of home runs were hit in that context and nothing will change that. Just leave it alone.
For those who want to diminish Bonds’ achievements I point out what experts have said: No steroid ever made a player a better hitter. If Bonds’ increased strength due to working out with steroids enabled him to hit a ball farther, then let’s estimate how many of his home runs during the steroids era became home runs due to a steroid-strength effect. How many more feet on average would a baseball fly due to the steroid-strength effect? Five feet? Ten feet? Then let’s examine each Bonds home run during the steroid era for those that became home runs by that number of feet and eliminate that number from his total. See the absolute absurdity here? Leave baseball history alone.
But for those who want to adjust or reduce numbers that were put up in a particular historical context to reflect today’s standards, I suggest we adjust Babe Ruth’s numbers to reflect that he did not have to bat against the Bob Gibsons and Fergie Jenkinses of his day. If we take Gibson’s strikeout numbers and extrapolate them to Ruth’s at-bats using some algorithm or model to arrive at a new race-adjusted home run total for Ruth, we are being just as ridiculous as those who want to throw out Bonds’ totals. And how did Ty Cobb, an avowed and committed racist, get into the Hall of Fame? Was it because his attitudes and beliefs were not so out of line for his historical context? Racism is worse than steroids. Isn’t it?
All of these influences, steroids, racial exclusions, dead balls, whatever, are in the past; leave them alone. There is no positive outcome available to Major League Baseball from conducting an investigation into the past. All this investigation will accomplish is to provide a platform for steroid news throughout the season. To whom is baseball responding by conducting this investigation? Certainly not the 75 million fans who attended games in 2005 and the hundreds of millions who watched games on TV and the Internet and listened on the radio. There simply has been no outcry from baseball’s customers about steroids. Is this investigation for Congress? Journalists? Leave it alone.
The commissioner’s office has produced a resoundingly successful World Baseball Classic, with huge implications for baseball’s future on a global scale. Focus on that potential, not the past. Baseball is the greatest game in the world, and Major League Baseball is the best baseball in the world. Barry Bonds will soon be the greatest home-run hitter in Major League Baseball history. Baseball is history. History is context. One can’t change history. Just leave it alone and love this great game.
Z. Dwight Billingsly is the managing director of Team Sports Business Initiative.