Fresno State Gets Fresh Start With Bartko Kingsford Charcoal Bags To Feature O'Bannon Northwestern's Phillips Talks New NCAA Role Big 12's Bowlsby Made $2.5M In '13-14 SDSU, Oregon Specify Cost Of Attendance Utah AD Explains Price Increases Purdue Cuts Football Season-Ticket Prices Turner Bullish On NCAA Tourney Ad Sales Missouri's Move To SEC Paying Off So Far Tennessee's Handling Of Legal Issues Questioned
Upcoming Conferences and Events
SBD/August 12, 2014/Colleges
NCAA Still Concerned Over Ruling In O'Bannon Case, Asks If Applies To Current Athletes
Published August 12, 2014
LAND OF CONFUSION: In S.F., Ann Killion writes, "I don't know exactly what last week's ruling ... means for college sports. But I'm certain of one thing: It has left everyone, on both sides, confused." For the moment, "all we're really left with are endless questions and the specter of more lawsuits" (S.F. CHRONICLE, 8/12). GRANTLAND's Charles Pierce wrote the "problem is that the section of the ruling concerning" the players' pay cap is "so unclear that whether the $5,000 number on the trust is a floor or a ceiling depends vitally on which Google link you happen to click." Lawyers from both sides are "howling for clarifications, and even the NCAA seems utterly baffled." Nothing about college sports "ever is going to be uncomplicated, it appears" (GRANTLAND.com, 8/11). But in L.A., Chris Dufresne writes the "picture is a tad clearer," and the ruling "wasn't, as it turned out, a crushing blow to the NCAA." Wilken's ruling was a "fairly reasonable assessment of the uncomfortable relationship between capitalism and the socialist-minded NCAA." She said that players should "be paid for use of their names, images and likeness while in college, yet fell short of turning college sports into the free-market Ayn Rand Institute." Dufresne writes the $5,000 cap "seems reasonable to me, and I don't see how it dramatically alters the landscape" (L.A. TIMES, 8/12).
IT'S ALWAYS SONNY: In N.Y., Joe Nocera writes former adidas, Nike and Reebok exec Sonny Vaccaro is "as responsible for the O'Bannon case as anyone." Vaccaro "first got the idea for the lawsuit in the late 1990s, around the time that ESPN bought Classic Sports Network" for $175M. The players in those games have "long since left college, yet they have no rights to their names and likenesses, just as had been the case when they were in school." Vaccaro wondered how that could "possibly be OK?" Vaccaro in '07 "quit his final job in the sneaker industry ... to devote his time to fighting the NCAA, an organization he had come to loathe." Vaccaro yesterday said, "Do I wish the decision had gone further? Sure. It vindicated people like me, who have been voices in the wilderness for so long" (N.Y. TIMES, 8/12).
POWER PLAY: The NCAA D-I BOD last week also voted to give autonomy to the Power 5 conferences, and Tulane AD Rick Dickson said that his university, along with the other American Athletic Conference programs, were "ready for the new governance structure." He said that Tulane will "adhere to what the Power Five decide to do with cost of attendance." Dickson: "We've been actively participating in the American Athletic Conference. So we've collectively discussed and taken positions on this. And I can tell you that unanimously all of our schools have voted to make certain that in the event that that legislation for cost of attendance takes place, we will concur with that. It kind of fits into our overall outlook and objective in our partnership with our student-athletes. We take care of our kids" (NOLA.com, 8/11). In Tucson, Greg Hansen notes athletes in the Power 5 are "likely to be given an extra $2,000 to $5,000 a year for expenses not covered by a typical scholarship." That is "spending money, which is overdue and well-deserved." The "most meaningful part of any potential revenue sharing will be extended medical and insurance benefits and common-sense care for a former athlete" (ARIZONA DAILY STAR, 8/12).
WHAT ABOUT THE LITTLE GUYS? In St. Paul, John Shipley writes, "What becomes of the college sports that aren't very big business?" Univ. of Oregon Warsaw Sports Marketing Center Dir Paul Swangard said, "Post-ruling, there are going to be a lot of schools saying, 'How can we justify carrying these things forward?'" Univ. of Minnesota baseball coach John Anderson "concurs," and sees the NCAA "ready to commit more resources to football when most athletics departments already struggle to stay in the black." Anderson: "Any (baseball) team in the northern half of the country has to feel threatened" (ST. PAUL PIONEER PRESS, 8/12).