Minute Media Closes On $15M Investment Round ESPN Still Hurting Disney Quarterly Results Under Armour's Kevin Plank Defends Company MLB Postseason Boosts 21st Century Fox' Q2 Callaway Golf Posts Solid Financials Under Armour Posts Tepid Forecast For '17 No Bidders For Bauer Hockey's Parent Co. ISC Revenues Up For '16, Admissions Down StubHub Q4 Results Show 20% Jump From '15 Sports Owners Investing In Tech Startups
SBD/October 22, 2013/Finance
Arian Foster Injury Comes At Bad Time For Fantex; Pundits Poke Holes In Investment
Published October 22, 2013
RISK & REWARD: SPORTS ON EARTH's Peter Richmond wrote if the Foster deal "isn't working out," Fantex "can take the Foster shares and convert them into another 'brand' if they so choose." Richmond: "My $50 is gone, while they use the money to bolster another listing corner of their brokerage service" (SPORTSONEARTH.com, 10/19). The GLOBE & MAIL's Tim Kiladze writes, "Over the long-term Fantex will invest in many more players, and if they end up being busts while Mr. Foster does well, all of those losses are netted out against the gains from Mr. Foster's revenue" (GLOBE & MAIL, 10/22). ESPN’s Bomani Jones said of the IPO, "You know who doesn't invest in the future of running backs? NFL teams, but you’re going to do it?" ESPN’s Tony Kornheiser said, "This sounds like a Ponzi scheme to me” (“PTI,” ESPN, 10/18). CBS' John Blackstone said, "The financial rewards are uncertain, but there may be more thrills in buying a share of a player than simply buying a trading card" ("Evening News," CBS, 10/18).
SMOKE & MIRRORS? THE VERGE's Adrianne Jeffries wrote Fantex's celebrity trading platform is an "innovative idea, but it's somewhat tangential to the company’s real business." Fantex is "primarily a marketing and 'brand enhancement' company, and the trading exchange is basically a clever way to hook big name clients." Fantex is "positioning the deal as stock in Foster, but buyers are actually getting common stock in Fantex Inc. -- and a very small amount of stock at that." All the Foster shares together "add up to 1 percent of Fantex, which means Foster shareholders have no influence on company decisions" (THEVERGE.com, 10/19). In DC, Neil Irwin wrote, "There's a lesson for investing buried in all this ... The more fun an investment is, the less likely it is a good investment" (WASHINGTONPOST.com, 10/18). Time magazine's Sean Gregory said, "Even if Arian Foster does well and makes lot of money, the 20 percent of his future earnings goes to Fantex, not necessarily to the individual investor. So it’s up to Fantex to pay a dividend to the individual investor and that's not guaranteed." Gregory: "The other way you can make money is by trading it on this new exchange, but this is a new exchange. There's no market established so you can have this stock and not enough people play this game and you're stuck with it" ("CBS This Morning," CBS, 10/19).