MLB Giants Payroll To Top $200M For First Time Lisa Borders Responds To Wiggins' Criticism Mitt Romney In Talks With Yankees For Small Stake Manfred: Talking To Players About Rules "Difficult" Orioles Exec VP Wouldn't Want A Trump First Pitch Baseball HOF Tour Returning For Second Season First Data Lands Rights To Mets' Fla. Complex Clark Calls MLB Rule Change Discussions "Ongoing" Four Brands Sign Up As WBC Global Sponsors Cubs Using "That's Cub" As '17 Marketing Slogan
SBD/May 13, 2013/Leagues and Governing Bodies
Columnists Call For Changes To MLB's Instant Replay After Several High-Profile Misses
Published May 13, 2013
THE NHL MODEL: In Detroit, Jamie Samuelsen wrote MLB needs to "take the replay decisions out of the hands of the on-field umpires." They "clearly don’t like instant replay, which is completely nonsensical." MLB should "set up a control room just like the NHL has." Since there are "up to 15 games a night, assign five games to three different officials." When a close play happens, they "buzz the crew chief, take a look at the video and make the call." Samuelsen: "No more of this silly running into a secret cave underneath the stands" (FREEP.com, 5/11). In Ft. Worth, Gil LeBreton wrote in an "increasingly high-tech society, in an age with TiVo and FaceTime, the two low-tech blunders last week were inexcusable." Replay reviews in MLB and the NFL "need to be handled independently, much in the same way" that the NHL handles them (FT. WORTH STAR-TELEGRAM, 5/12). In Pennsylvania, John Mehno wrote "no system is perfect, but the NHL's is far superior to MLB's." There is a "greater commitment to getting the calls right." Even the NFL "has a better system, with a replay official assigned to each game and seated in a booth." That "wouldn't be practical in baseball because of the number of games, so an NHL-styled system would work better" (ALTOONA MIRROR, 5/12).
DAMAGE CONTROL: MLB on Friday suspended umpire Fieldin Culbreth for allowing an illegal pitching change in Thursday's Angels-Astros game, and YAHOO SPORTS' Tim Brown wrote the league has "taken the proper course." In a game that "demands accountability and transparency from its organizations and their players, that often insists on the same from the commissioner's office and the players' union, the umpires are to be held to the same standard." There should be "suspensions and fines, and discipline should be publicized. Jobs should be at stake. After all, everybody else's is" (SPORTS.YAHOO.com, 5/10).