NBA Free Agency Begins With Money Flying Steelers Exploring '23 Super Bowl Bid Redskins DC Stadium Could Hinge On Name Change Top Rank Files Suit Against Al Haymon NHRA Leadership Undergoing Changes IndyCar's Miles Fires Back At Critics Of Race Conditions CVC Capital's Mackenzie: Make F1 More Exciting Chargers, Raiders Meet With L.A. Officials Daytona Int'l Speedway Holding Flag Exchange MLS Expected To Add "Core Player" Roster Spot
SBD/March 11, 2011/Leagues and Governing Bodies
NFL Labor Watch: De Smith Plans Friday Update For Players On Union's Plans
Published March 11, 2011
WANT MORE GREAT STORIES LIKE THIS?
CLICK ON ONE OF THESE BUTTONS
READY FOR A COURT SHOWDOWN? In Philadelphia, Paul Domowitch notes if the NFL and NFLPA cannot agree to a third extension of the CBA, the union "will likely decertify and play its hole card: Doty." Indiana Univ. School of Law Dean Gary Roberts said, "Judge Doty has had -- and I can't think of any way to say it without overstating it -- he has had a remarkable and extraordinary string of always ruling for the union. He has given them whatever they've wanted. Any case that goes to litigation usually has a plausible argument on each side. But I mean it's almost inconceivable that an objective, neutral judge would rule, in every single case -- case after case after case -- for the same side when both sides have plausible arguments" (PHILADELPHIA DAILY NEWS, 3/11). USA TODAY's Jarrett Bell notes beyond decertification, players are "expected to file antitrust lawsuits -- including a case that includes star quarterbacks Peyton Manning, Drew Brees and Tom Brady as plaintiffs -- that challenge a wide range of NFL operations." Franchise player tags, restricted free agency and the draft "all could be targeted in individual antitrust cases." NFL Exec VP & General Counsel Jeff Pash said, "It's no more or less of a threat than it's ever been. We've known for years that the union's strategy is to litigate -- to fake its own death and run to court. If they decide to do that, that's what they'll do, and we'll deal with it" (USA TODAY, 3/11).
FREE TO DO WHAT I WANT: SI.com's Peter King cited sources as saying that there is a "distinct possibility that trades and free agent movement could be allowed long before the two sides reach a new labor deal." It likely would not be allowed "until at least the middle of April, and maybe not 'til May," and would "center on the legal labyrinth the case could go through if the players choose to decertify." A longtime Doty observer noted Thursday that an injunction "could take up to a month to be issued under usual circumstances, and then the decision on whether the appeal would be allowed another week or two." A Friday decertification, then, "could lead to the league restarting business, as forced by the court, by late April, around the time of the April 28-30 NFL Draft (SI.com, 3/10).