MASN Taking Aim At MLB Advance To Nats Jeter Played No Role In Woods' Tribune Piece Twitter Impact On Sports Reporting Keeps Growing NBC Sports Sees Big F1 Gains Media Notes ESPN Draws Lowest "MNF" Rating Of '14 Finebaum Hosting Call-In Show During Iron Bowl FS North's Ratings Decline For Twins Games Continues App Review: Cavaliers For iPhone Cowboys-Giants Rating Lower On NBC
SBD/Issue 73/Sports Media
Pimp My Ride: Evel Knievel Crashes In Libel Suit
Published January 5, 2005
Appeals Court Upholds Dismissal
Of Knievel’s Libel Suit Against ESPN
The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in a 2-1 ruling upheld a federal judge’s dismissal of a libel suit filed against ESPN by Evel Knievel and his wife, Krystal, according to Bob Egelko of the S.F. CHRONICLE. After Knievel appeared at ESPN’s ’01 Action Sports & Music Awards, a photo from the event featuring Knievel with two women, one of whom was Krystal, was posted on ESPN.com with a caption reading: “Evel Knievel proves that you’re never too old to be a pimp.” The court ruled that “no reasonable reader would have interpreted ‘pimp’ literally.” Judge A. Wallace Tashima, citing one Web site’s definition of pimp as slang for “cool,” said the caption “was most likely intended as a compliment.” Tashima added that “at the very least, any reasonable reader would have considered the caption ‘an attempt at humor.’” In a dissenting opinion, Judge Carlos Bea, citing Knievel’s claim “that some business clients canceled endorsement deals after the photo appeared,” stated that “a jury should decide how the average reader would interpret the caption” (S.F. CHRONICLE, 1/5).