Carriage Standoff Hurts TWC's Revenue Projections MASN, Nationals File Preservation Rights Petitions SEC Schools Prepare For Network Launch WWE To Cut 7% Of Workforce People & Personalities Final Ratings: Brickyard 400, UFC On Fox Charter Nearing Deal With SEC Net Ombudsman Addresses Smith Comments "College GameDay" To Start In Ft. Worth Stephen A. Smith Suspended One Week
Upcoming Conferences and Events
FOX EXPERIMENT WITH NO PLAY-BY-PLAY: REVIEWS ARE MIXED
Published December 11, 1995
Several media writers commented on Fox's use of Terry Bradshaw and Jimmy Johnson as co-analysts during Saturday's Chargers-Cardinals game without the use of a play-by-play announcer. USA TODAY'S Michael Hiestand says there were "plenty of glitches and dead air," but that the two improved as the game went on (USA TODAY, 12/11). In Miami, Barry Jackson writes the "telecast was a yawner" as the two "simply spent too much time analyzing individual plays and strategy in a game between two mediocre teams." They "should have talked about other hot issues -- like teams changing cities" (MIAMI HERALD, 12/10). Larry Stewart in L.A. writes, "Nice try, but it didn't quite work ... It really wasn't a bad telecast. It just wasn't a particularly good one, and certainly wasn't revolutionary" (L.A. TIMES, 12/10). The Baltimore SUN's Milton Kent writes, "Silence may be golden, but not in a football telecast" (Baltimore SUN, 12/11). In Toronto, Rob Longley calls the telecast it an experiment "gone awry" (TORONTO SUN, 12/11). In Chicago, Steve Nidetz notes without a play-by-play voice, there "were some dead spots" (CHICAGO TRIBUNE, 12/11). Phil Mushnick of the N.Y. POST pans the broadcast, writing, "Thank goodness Fox didn't choose to abandon graphics along with the play-by-play man" (N.Y. POST, 12/11). But in Washington, Dick Hellar calls the combination a "winner" and writes the pair "just might put a lot of play by play announcers out of work" (WASHINGTON TIMES, 12/11). In Atlanta, Prentis Rogers calls it a "qualified success," but suggests Fox enhance the audio of the public address announcer to help viewers with play-by-play details (ATLANTA CONSTITUTION, 12/11).